When the menu prompt appears, order based on the clues she gives during conversation:
: Use a fast car or motorcycle; a slow vehicle makes it nearly impossible to fill the required meter in time.
Your primary goal in this phase is to build initial trust without appearing overly aggressive. Initial Conversation Choices
The classic choice. Gives a steady +2 Romance boost.
Always choose to Ask a follow-up question when she shares a story. This builds the "Empathy" stat.